The closure decides the change, not the print
A footie is only as easy as its closure. A two-way zipper and a button-up front solve the same problem—getting a baby in and out without a struggle—but they do it in opposite ways. One is built for speed and middle-of-the-night diaper changes; the other is built for gentle, low-fuss dressing. Neither is universally better. The right choice depends on your baby's age, how often you're changing diapers, and how much you value a particular fabric feel.
Two real styles from the Posh Baby catalog show the difference clearly: the Tun Tun (Peru) Cotton Two Way Zipper Footie in Sailboats and the Babyface Long Sleeve Button-Up Footie in Vintage Pink Swans. Both cover the same 0–12M size range and both are machine washable, but their closures and fabric blends point to different daily routines.
Zipper vs buttons: a side-by-side look at daily use
- Diaper changes: The Tun Tun two-way zipper is designed for quick and simple diaper changes, so you can open just the bottom portion without fully undressing your baby. A button-up footie like the Babyface opens fully from the top, which can mean more unfastening during a change.
- Dressing and undressing: The Babyface button-up closure is described as gentle and easy, without the fumbling of snaps or the disruption of a full zip—a good match for newborns and young infants who need low-fuss changes. The Tun Tun zipper is a single pull, which is faster once you're used to it.
- Fabric feel: The Tun Tun is 96% cotton and 4% elastane—soft, stretchy, and familiar. The Babyface blends 50% organic cotton, 45% Modal, and 5% elasthane for a silky drape and softness that parents notice immediately. If fabric feel matters most, the Modal blend is the standout.
- Care: The Tun Tun is machine washable and air dry. The Babyface fabric is described as holding its shape and softness wash after wash, but the supplied information does not specify a full care routine beyond that. Check the garment label before washing either style.
Tun Tun Sailboats: the two-way zipper option
- Tun Tun (Peru) - Cotton Two Way Zipper Footie - Sailboats: Two-way zipper design allows for quick and simple diaper changes. This is the core advantage of a two-way zipper footie: you can change a diaper without fully unzipping the top, which matters most at night or with a wriggly baby.

Tun Tun (Peru) - Cotton Two Way Zipper Footie - Sailboats - Tun Tun (Peru) - Cotton Two Way Zipper Footie - Sailboats: Made from a soft blend of 96% cotton and 4% elastane. High cotton content with a little stretch gives a breathable, familiar feel. Elastane helps the footie move with your baby rather than binding.
- Tun Tun (Peru) - Cotton Two Way Zipper Footie - Sailboats: Available in sizes 0-3M, 3-6M, 6-9M, and 9-12M. This is a standard infant size run. It does not extend into toddler sizes, so plan for the first year.
- Tun Tun (Peru) - Cotton Two Way Zipper Footie - Sailboats: Machine washable and air dry. Simple care instructions that fit a busy household. Air drying helps preserve the elastane over time.
Babyface Vintage Pink Swans: the button-up option
- Babyface - Long Sleeve Button-Up Footie - Vintage Pink Swans: Button-up design for gentle, easy dressing, without the fumbling of snaps or the disruption of a full zip. This is the button-up baby footie's main selling point: a calm, controlled dressing routine, especially for newborns and young infants.

Babyface - Long Sleeve Button-Up Footie - Vintage Pink Swans - Babyface - Long Sleeve Button-Up Footie - Vintage Pink Swans: Crafted from 50% organic cotton, 45% Modal, and 5% elasthane. The Modal content gives this footie a silky drape and softness that distinguishes it from an all-cotton style. The elastane provides stretch.
- Babyface - Long Sleeve Button-Up Footie - Vintage Pink Swans: Available in sizes 0-3M (56), 3-6M (62), 6-9M (68), and 9-12M (74). The same infant size range as the Tun Tun, with European size equivalents in parentheses. Use these to cross-check against other brands.
- Babyface - Long Sleeve Button-Up Footie - Vintage Pink Swans: The fabric holds its shape and softness wash after wash. Durability matters for a footie worn frequently. This suggests the Modal blend is not a one-season piece, though the supplied information does not include a full care routine.
Which closure suits your routine?
If you are changing diapers several times a night and want to minimize disruption, the two-way zipper on the Tun Tun Sailboats footie is the more practical choice. The zipper opens from the bottom, so you can keep your baby's upper body covered and warm during a change. The cotton-rich fabric is soft and breathable, and the sailboat print is a gender-neutral option.
If your priority is gentle dressing—especially with a newborn or a baby who dislikes being manipulated—the Babyface button-up footie offers a slower, more controlled approach. The button front opens fully, and the Modal blend feels noticeably silkier against the skin. The Vintage Pink Swans print is a more traditional, heirloom-style look.
One tradeoff to consider: buttons take more time to fasten than a zipper, which can matter during a crying diaper change. Zippers, on the other hand, require careful positioning to avoid pinching skin—though the two-way design reduces how much you need to unzip. Neither style is confirmed as safe-sleep or car-seat compatible in the supplied information, so treat them as everyday sleepwear and daywear, not as sleep-sack or car-seat substitutes.
Details that may influence your choice
- Price: The Tun Tun is listed at $32.83 (compared to $52.95), and the Babyface at $28.49 (compared to $45.95). Both are in a similar range, so closure and fabric are the main differentiators.
- Print and style: Sailboats is a playful, gender-neutral print; Vintage Pink Swans is a softer, more classic look. Both are footies with long sleeves and covered feet.
- Size range: Both styles stop at 9-12M. If you need larger sizes, you will need to look beyond these two options.
- Care instructions: The Tun Tun is machine washable and air dry. The Babyface care routine is not fully specified in the supplied information—check the label. Neither product record mentions dryer use.



