Moonlight Prance

The tabs are genuinely sturdy, and the hedgehog scene is adorable. My little one giggles at the dancing fox every time, then actually settles down for bed. A real favorite.

My two-year-old insists on this one every single night now, and the hedgehog tab is the first thing she reaches for. The tabs glide smoothly even after weeks of her yanking them, which honestly surprised me.

My two-year-old asks for this every night now, mostly to make the foxes dance across the page. The hedgehog tab sticks a little unless you pull it just right, but that's honestly the only thing keeping it from five stars.